This post presents a systematic account of Augustine’s concept of God, focusing on God as ultimate reality, changeless, creative, eternal, and the highest good. It explains key metaphysical ideas such as creation out of nothing, the nature of time, the Great Chain of Being, and the relation between goodness and reality, while comparing Augustine with Greek philosophy.

---

Ultimate Reality: Religious and God-First Approach

1. Ultimate Reality: Secular and Religious Perspectives

• Metaphysics is the study of ultimate reality.
• Greek philosophers describe ultimate reality in secular-philosophical terms:
  Plato (Forms), Heraclitus (Flux), Parmenides (Being), Aristotle (Substance).
• Augustine accepts that Greek philosophy points toward ultimate reality but holds that it gives only a partial understanding.
• Augustine gives a religious interpretation of ultimate reality and identifies it as God.
• Thus, the difference is mainly one of interpretation and perspective, not of subject matter.

2. Knowing Ultimate Reality through Effects

• Ultimate reality cannot be known directly through sense perception.
• Plato holds that Forms are known through reason or intellect, not the senses.
• Augustine holds that God is known through divine illumination, not sensory experience.
• In both cases, ultimate reality is known indirectly, by observing its effects.
• The order and intelligibility of the world point beyond themselves to a deeper cause.

3. Electron Analogy: Knowing the Invisible by Its Effects

• Some real entities cannot be directly observed (e.g., electrons).
• Electrons are known through their observable effects, such as tracks in a cloud chamber.
• This shows that direct visibility is not necessary for reality.
• Similarly, God and Forms are not directly perceived but inferred from their effects.
• This analogy explains an epistemic method, not a scientific proof of God.

4. Augustine’s Hints for the Existence of God

• Augustine does not offer formal logical proofs for God’s existence.
• He provides philosophical hints or indications.
• The order, harmony, and beauty of the world suggest a Creator.
• Eternal and changeless truths (mathematical and logical truths) exist.
• Since the human mind is changeable, these truths must originate in an eternal source, namely God.
• Divine illumination: just as the eyes need light to see, the mind needs God’s light to know truth.

5. God-First and Reason-First Epistemology

• God-first epistemology (Augustine): God’s illumination is the precondition of all knowledge.
• Reason exists but functions properly only under divine illumination.
• Reason-first epistemology (modern philosophy): knowledge begins with reason alone.
• Modern philosophers first construct a secular theory of knowledge, then attempt to prove God.
• This difference later shapes the divide between divine theology and natural theology.

Summary

Augustine interprets ultimate reality from a religious perspective and identifies it as God. Like Greek philosophers, he accepts that ultimate reality cannot be known through the senses but only indirectly. By observing order, effects, and eternal truths, the mind moves beyond the visible world. Augustine’s epistemology begins with God as the necessary condition of knowledge, unlike modern approaches that begin with reason.

---

God as Changeless and Perfect Reality

1. Perfect Reality as Changeless

• Augustine describes God (ultimate reality) as unchanging or immutable.
• Change is a feature of the physical world, not of ultimate reality.
• What changes is temporary, dependent, and imperfect.
• Ultimate reality must be eternal and fully real, and therefore changeless.
• Both Plato and Augustine deny change only of ultimate reality, not of the physical world.

2. Perfection Necessarily Implies Changelessness

• Perfection means complete fullness, lacking nothing.
• Change implies either improvement or deterioration.
• A perfect being cannot improve, because there is nothing higher to reach.
• A perfect being cannot deteriorate, because that would mean loss of perfection.
• Therefore, if God is perfect, God must be changeless.
• For Augustine, immutability is a necessary attribute of God.

3. Relation Between Changing World and Changeless God

• A central metaphysical problem arises:
  How can a changeless God create and relate to a changing world?
• Plato faced a similar problem in explaining the relation between changeless Forms and the changing world.
• Augustine does not give a fully systematic solution to this problem.
• However, Augustine clearly holds that:
  • The world is created by God.
  • Therefore, the world is real, not an illusion.
  • The world has dependent and lesser reality, not absolute reality.
• This tension significantly shapes Augustine’s metaphysics and theology.

Summary

Augustine holds that God, as ultimate reality, must be changeless and perfect. Change belongs to the created physical world and indicates dependence and imperfection. Since perfection excludes both improvement and decline, God must be immutable. However, this leads to a metaphysical difficulty regarding how a changeless God relates to a changing world, a problem Augustine acknowledges but does not fully systematize.

---

God as Creative Ultimate Reality

1. Creativity as Creation out of Nothing (Creatio ex Nihilo)

• For Augustine, God’s second essential property is creativity.
• “Creative” has a strict philosophical meaning: God creates without using any pre-existing matter.
• Creatio ex nihilo means creation without a material cause, not creation from a substance called “nothing.”
• Example of creation out of something:
  A carpenter makes a table using wood. The table is new, but the wood already existed.
• Human creativity always works like this—something is made from something.
• God’s creativity is different: the world is created when nothing material existed at all.
• Absolute creativity, therefore, belongs only to God.

2. Why Pre-existing Matter Limits God’s Power

• Scriptural basis: The Bible (Genesis) teaches that God created the world from nothing.
• Metaphysical basis: Using pre-existing matter would place a limit on God.
• Example:
  If a cook makes tea, the quality of the tea depends on the quality of the milk.
• If the milk is bad, the tea cannot be perfect.
• Similarly, if God used pre-existing matter, creation would depend on the quality of that matter.
• This would make God’s act dependent on something else, which contradicts divine omnipotence.
• Therefore, God must create without any material constraint.

3. Greek Views versus Augustine on Creation

• Most Greek philosophers believed either:
  • the world is eternal, or
  • the world is made from pre-existing matter.
• In Plato, the Demiurge shapes matter according to Forms, like a craftsman.
• Creation is understood as ordering, not producing existence itself.
• Plato explains imperfection and evil as due to the limitations of matter.
• Augustine rejects this view because it makes God’s creative act limited and incomplete.

4. Creator and Created World: Neither Identity nor Independence

• Augustine explains reality using the distinction between Creator (God) and creature (world).
• If God and world are the same, this leads to pantheism.
• Pantheism claims that God is the world and the world is God.
• This is a heresy because:
  • God would change when the world changes.
  • Evil in the world would imply evil in God.
  • God would no longer be a personal creator.
• If God and world are completely separate, the world becomes independent.
• An independent world could exist without God, which denies divine omnipotence.
• Augustine’s position:
  The world is not identical with God, yet it cannot exist without God.
• The world is distinct but totally dependent.

5. Creation as a Free Act, Not a Necessity

• Creation is a free act of God, not something God is forced to do.
• Free act means acting by choice; necessity means acting automatically.
• Example of necessity:
  Breathing—one cannot choose to stop breathing indefinitely.
• Example of free act:
  Giving a gift—one may give it or choose not to.
• Augustine rejects the Neoplatonic idea of emanation, where creation flows automatically from God.
• God creates the world by choice, not by compulsion.
• God could have chosen not to create at all.

6. Form, Matter, and the Visible World

• The visible world is a combination of form and matter.
• Form gives structure, order, and intelligibility.
• Matter provides the material basis of physical things.
• In Augustine:
  • Forms exist in the mind of God as divine ideas.
  • Matter is newly created by God out of nothing.
• Unlike Plato, forms do not exist independently, and matter is not eternal.
• Everything changeable in the visible world is therefore created and dependent.

7. Seed Principles and Theistic Development

• Augustine holds that God created everything in the beginning, as Genesis states.
• Not all beings appeared in their final form at once.
• Some were created as seed principles (rationes seminales).
• These are hidden potentials placed in creation by God.
• Over time, these seeds develop and unfold into plants, animals, and new forms of life.
• Difference from biological evolution:
  • Modern evolution explains change through random mutation and natural selection.
  • Augustine rejects randomness.
• His view is often called theistic evolution:
  • Development occurs over time,
  • but according to God’s original plan.
• God remains the primary cause, even when change appears gradual.

Summary

Augustine understands God as creative in the strict sense of creating the world out of nothing. Creation ex nihilo preserves God’s omnipotence and distinguishes his view from Greek philosophy. The world is neither identical with God nor independent of Him but exists in total dependence on its Creator. Creation is a free divine act, the visible world combines form and matter, and all later developments unfold according to God’s pre-planned seed principles.

---

God as Eternal and Beyond Time

1. God as Eternal Reality

• Augustine holds that God is eternal.
• Eternal does not mean infinite time.
• It means:
  • no beginning,
  • no end,
  • no change,
  • no succession.
• God is unchanging, uncreated, and absolute.
• God does not exist in time; rather, time exists within creation.
• Eternity is timeless existence, not endless duration.

2. The Question: “What Was God Doing Before Creation?”

• Critics asked: What was God doing before creating the world?
• A famous humorous reply was: God was preparing hell for such questioners.
• Augustine treats this as a serious philosophical problem.
• The question assumes:
  • that time existed before creation.
• If God waited and then created, this would imply:
  • a change in God.
• Since God is changeless, this assumption must be rejected.

3. Creation, Change, and Eternity

• If God created the world at a particular moment, it seems:
  • God moved from not creating → creating.
• This would imply change in God, which is impossible.
• Augustine’s solution:
  • time itself is created along with the world.
• Therefore:
  • there was no “before” creation,
  • God is not earlier or later than the world.
• God exists outside time, while time belongs to creation.

4. Thought Experiment: Why the Present Has No Duration

• Augustine analyzes time as past, present, and future.
• Past no longer exists.
• Future does not yet exist.
• Only the present seems to exist.
• Augustine asks: Can the present have duration?
• If a present moment has length, it can be divided into:
  • an earlier part (past),
  • a later part (future).
• This applies to:
  • centuries,
  • years,
  • months,
  • days,
  • hours,
  • seconds.
• Even a second can be divided into past and future.
• Therefore:
  • the present has no duration.
• The present is a point, where future becomes past.

5. Time as Memory, Attention, and Expectation

• Augustine asks: If time has no duration, how do we measure it?
• His answer:
  • Time exists in the mind, not as an external object.
• He defines:
  • Past = memory,
  • Present = attention,
  • Future = expectation.
• We do not measure past events themselves,
  • we measure their impressions in the mind.
• Time is therefore experienced subjectively, though change in the world is real.
• Since the mind is created, time begins with creation.

6. Human Time and Divine Eternity

• Humans experience time successively:
  • one moment after another.
• We hold:
  • memories of the past,
  • expectations of the future,
    together in the present.
• God’s knowledge is not successive.
• God does not wait for events to occur.
• For God:
  • past, present, and future are all present at once.
• This description is analogical, not literal psychology.

7. Analogies: Psalm and Mozart

• Augustine’s Psalm example:
  • When reciting a psalm:
    • words already spoken are in memory,
    • words being spoken are in attention,
    • words yet to come are in expectation.
  • The whole psalm exists together in the mind.
• Mozart analogy (modern illustration):
  • A listener hears music note by note over time.
  • A composer may grasp the entire composition at once.
• Similarly:
  • the universe unfolds in time for us,
  • but is present as a whole to God.
• God sees the entire timeline in one eternal “now”.

Summary

Augustine understands God as eternal in the sense of being beyond time, not as existing for infinite temporal duration. Through a careful analysis of time, he shows that the present has no duration and that time exists in the mind as memory, attention, and expectation. Since the mind is created, time begins with creation, making questions about “before creation” meaningless. God, unlike humans, comprehends the entire history of the universe in a single eternal present.

---

God as the All-Good and Supreme Reality

1. God as the Highest Good (Summum Bonum)

• Augustine holds that God is all-good, that is, the highest good (summum bonum).
• God is not one good being among others.
• God alone is good in Himself and self-sufficient.
• All other things are good not by themselves, but because they come from God.
• Therefore, God is the ultimate source of all goodness, value, truth, and beauty.

2. Hierarchical Structure of Reality (Great Chain of Being – Idea)

• Augustine explains reality as hierarchically ordered, an idea later called the Great Chain of Being.
• This term is not used by Augustine, but the concept is clearly present in his philosophy.
• Reality is arranged like a ladder, from lowest to highest.
• At the lowest level is near non-being or nothingness.
• At the highest level is God, who possesses full being and full goodness.
• Everything else exists between these two extremes, with varying degrees of reality.

3. Relation between Being, Reality, Goodness, and Value

• For Augustine, being and goodness always go together.
• More being = more reality = more goodness = higher value.
• Less being = less reality = less goodness = lower value.
• Example:
  • A stone exists but has no life → low degree of being.
  • An animal has life and sensation → higher degree of being.
  • A human being has life, reason, and language → still higher degree.
• Moral value also follows this order.
• Evil is not a thing or substance; it is the privation (lack) of being and goodness.

4. Greek Background and Augustine’s Use of It

• Plato:
  • The Form of the Good is the highest reality.
  • What is most real is also most good.
  • Goodness is mainly intellectual and metaphysical.
• Plotinus (Neoplatonism):
  • Reality flows from the One by emanation.
  • As distance from the One increases, being and goodness decrease.
• Augustine accepts the link between reality and goodness.
• But he rejects emanation and replaces it with creation.
• The world does not flow from God by necessity; it is freely created.

5. Creation versus Emanation

• In emanation, the world is a necessary extension of God.
• In creation, the world is distinct from God but entirely dependent on Him.
• Augustine insists:
  • God and world are not identical (to avoid pantheism).
  • The world is not independent of God.
• This preserves:
  • God’s transcendence,
  • God’s perfection,
  • and the moral hierarchy of reality.
• The hierarchical order of beings is therefore a created order, not God Himself.

6. Different Meanings of “Good” in Greek and Christian Thought

• Aristotle’s God (Unmoved Mover):
  • Perfect and good.
  • Thinks only of itself.
  • Does not care for human beings.
  • Cannot enter personal relationships.
• Plato’s Demiurge:
  • Rational and good.
  • Orders the world intelligently.
  • But is not loving or personally involved.
• Augustine’s God:
  • All-good and loving.
  • Personally cares for every individual.
  • Can maintain a personal relationship with human beings.
• Christian goodness is therefore personal, loving, and relational, not merely rational.

7. Ultimate Reality and Human Desire

• Augustine holds that human beings seek happiness, peace, and rest.
• Our understanding of ultimate reality reflects our deepest desire.
• Plato and Aristotle primarily desired knowledge, so they conceived ultimate reality intellectually.
• Augustine desired peace, love, and fulfilment.
• Therefore, he understands God as:
  • caring,
  • responsive,
  • loving,
  • like a father.
• Example:
  • A hungry child imagines God as bread.
  • A philosopher imagines God as truth.
• God is all-good because all human desires ultimately find their rest in Him.

Summary

Augustine understands God as the highest and self-sufficient good (summum bonum), from whom all created goodness derives. Reality is hierarchically ordered: the more a thing exists, the more goodness and value it possesses. Evil is not a substance but a lack of being and goodness. Unlike Greek philosophy, Augustine presents God not only as rationally perfect but also as personally loving, capable of fulfilling the deepest human longing for peace, love, and rest.